Explore by Agency

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

The country's largest health insurer, and one of its most powerful sources of evidence.

What
CMS
does

CMS runs Medicare, Medicaid, and the Health Insurance Marketplace, covering more Americans than at any point in its history. Its data and payment experiments are among the most powerful evidence tools in government.

Where the structure falls short

CMS launches payment models faster than it can evaluate them, lets temporary coverage become permanent without the promised evidence, and relies on payment systems that researchers now depend on for data.

What the Blueprint recommends

Register CMMI model evaluations up front
Leadership can act
Requires Congress

Require CMMI to publish its evaluation plan before a model launches, and bar an unregistered launch from expansion until it's fixed.

Separate model designers from evaluators
Leadership can act
Requires Congress

Separate the people who design and run CMMI models from the people who evaluate them.

Show how findings reach the Actuary
Leadership can act

Document how CMMI's evaluation findings translate into the Office of the Actuary's cost certifications.

Fix temporary coverage
Leadership can act
Requires Congress

Say clearly when it ends, and let it expire after five years unless it is deliberately renewed.

Fund evidence when no company will
Requires Congress

Establish federal funding to generate the evidence Medicare needs when no manufacturer has a reason to pay for the study.

Turn on the CMS-AHRQ partnership
Can Start Now
Requires Congress

Make the long-standing CMS-AHRQ partnership operational, with AHRQ assessing treatments Medicare is deciding whether to cover.

Fix Medicare Advantage data
Leadership can act
Requires Congress

Bring Medicare Advantage encounter data up to research quality, with authority to enforce the standards.

Standardize access to Medicaid data
Leadership can act

Standardize researcher access to Medicaid data and improve its quality and comparability.

Each recommendation is tagged to show who has the authority to act and what is required to make the change:

  • Can Start Now: Officials can begin this today using authority they already have. No new decision from agency leadership is required.
  • Leadership Can Act: Agency or department leadership must make a decision, but they can do so using authority the department already has. No new law is required.
  • Requires Congress: Congressional action is required. The change cannot happen without new legislation.